24 Comments
User's avatar
Darren Watson's avatar

They are definitely a type, eh? Cough, cough... Billy TK Jr.

Expand full comment
Irene Fluit's avatar

Nice work Paula.

Do these people just think that they can BS their way through life to important roles and not think that their lies will eventually catch them out? Perhaps they think that if they put up enough front everyone will believe them....

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Thank you Irene. Yes, I'd like to know that too. I wonder whether in the process of convincing everyone else they end up convincing themselves.

Expand full comment
Caryl Forrest's avatar

The Wilce story is curious because any role in Defence at his level would require SIS clearance. It appears the SIS didn't pick up the phone and ring their British counterparts.

Expand full comment
Tadhg Stopford's avatar

You could be talking about NACT1st Paula.

Nice piece

Expand full comment
Lucy Conway's avatar

It’s also interesting, to me anyway, that we have a Tall Poppy thing where we tear people down who are actually often legitimately tall, and yet let these liars slip through time and again.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Good point, I hadn’t thought of it like that.

Expand full comment
Michael Stevens's avatar

Thanks for this. From when I first read your article a few weeks back I did wo just what the various HR departments had been doing. Bizarre that not one thought to check his background- or perhaps it isn’t - perhaps they don’t really do their jobs that well.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

I wonder if they just do a quick google! Because when you do that, at face value everything could look legit

Expand full comment
Michael Stevens's avatar

But they’re paid to do more than just that surely? I’ve only been asked to provide evidence of my qualifications once when job hunting.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Yes,surely!

Expand full comment
Jen n Hen's avatar

I do remember that expose on Mr Elice - his hubris was breathtaking! It would have been hilarious except for the implications of his deceit. I wonder whether the people who interviewed & appointed him were investigated for their part in the mess?!

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

I must go back and re-read the results of those investigations. You’d like to think some lessons would be learned..

Expand full comment
Jen n Hen's avatar

A follow up story perhaps?!

Expand full comment
Martin Samson's avatar

So little diligence, and so much potential for damage. Surely his JP credentials should be withdrawn.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

I must follow up on that point since said he was “resigning from everything”.

Expand full comment
Martin Samson's avatar

Please. Your article rocked. There is something endlessly fascinating about these Walter Mittys, and our ability to have them glide through society like Teflon - until they can’t. There’s so many. Is it a combination of our innate trust, their willingness to exploit it and a touch of bumbling ineptitude. Love it.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Love this summation!

Expand full comment
Leigh's avatar

I’m fascinated by the personality types who “big up” themselves… particularly people who pose as Drs. The amount of self belief!!

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

It’s intriguing isn’t it? Any psychologists reading this?!

Yes those who pose as doctors.. that’s a whole other level

Expand full comment
Sarah Whitcombe-Dobbs's avatar

Yes - but too sensible (I like to think!) to comment on individuals we haven’t assessed. But I agree - super interesting profile eh, to commit, over time, to such ludicrous deceit. Not a lack of intelligence, in these cases, and often really personable

people. Fascinating! P.s. love your work.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Rightly so! And yes, all undoubtedly intelligent and personable. And thank you:)

Expand full comment
Geoff Lawson's avatar

Interesting and fascinating article, thank you Paula.

Expand full comment
Paula Penfold's avatar

Thank you so much Geoff, appreciate you reading.

Expand full comment